Chase Jarvis Chase Jarvis
  • Photos
  • Projects
  • About
  • Blog
  • Book
Chase Jarvis Chase Jarvis
  • Photos
  • Projects
  • About
  • Blog
  • Book

War & Fashion – Intellectual Exercise or Gut Punch?

A few days ago Moni Basu of CNN published a provocative piece comparing the photography of War to the photography of Fashion.

Whether this is an absurd evocation, an intellectual exercise, or an astute reflection I’m not calling it. I can’t. But the idea of taking an individual photographer who has shot both war and fashion and juxtaposing images from the two bodies of work, was curious and very disturbing. At one end, sure, there’s the composition and technique – brilliantly and noticably similar…at the other end of the spectrum is the danger of belittling such a weighty topic as war with such a flippant topic as fashion. All in all, plenty of tension, which is why I thought this a worthy share.

I still don’t know what to think. Generally speaking its not a surprise that popular reactions worldwide to this piece have been swift and, dare I say it, overwhelmingly unflattering. Basu has been quick to defend herself by explaining:

We are not comparing war to fashion. We are comparing the photos that come from those disparate circumstances.

But can you compare the photos taken of disparate circumstances without comparing the circumstances themselves? It’s a big stretch to take for the sake of alliteration. Just as Basu took the scales to the two forms of photography, we should take them to her project. On the one hand, I understand the goal of juxtaposition for being evocative. Whether bravery or naiveté, it takes a large dose of both in large doses to dive right into the deep end, which is what she did.

This project will always be an invitation for serious criticism and judgment. Write what words you may write around the images, but sitting an image of American soldiers at the same table as runway models with the title “War & Fashion” at the head is a guaranteed poke with a sharp stick for many. Even for those opposed to war (or fashion for that matter).

I wrote about wartime photojournalists a few weeks ago in part to celebrate the individuals who took the photos but also to appreciate the work itself. Although I threw up a sequence of shots, each photo really deserves to stand on its own — such is the emotional impact they have. It’s hard to imagine comparing say, Eddie Adams’ iconic Vietnam photo to a model having her makeup put on.

I guess I “get” it, but I’m not sure on the issue of taste. But then, I’m no Moni Basu.

[If this topic is unsettling to begin with, please don’t scroll down to look at the photos. And please no ranting. Opinion yes, thrashing, no. This is intended/shared with the goal of critical reflection and respectful discussion only.]

Baghdad, Iraq. 2003. Photo by Christopher Anderson / Magnum Photos.

NYC, USA. February, 2008. Photo by Christopher Anderson / Magnum Photos.

Beirut, Lebanon. August, 2006. Photo by Christopher Anderson / Magnum Photos.

NYC, USA. February, 2008. Photo by Christopher Anderson / Magnum Photos.

Cairo, Eqypt. 2011. Photo by Paolo Pellegrin / Magnum Photos.

New York, 2005. Photo by Paolo Pellegrin / Magnum Photos.

Baghdad, Iraq. November, 2004. Photo by Jerome Sessini / Magnum Photos.

Milan, Italy. September, 2012. Photo by Jerome Sessini / Magnum Photos.

Cairo, Egypt. February, 2011. Photo by Alex Majoli / Magnum Photos.

NYC, USA. 2009. Photo by Alex Majoli / Magnum Photos.

Related Posts

10 Things Every Creative Person (That’s YOU) Must Learn
051026_ChaseJarvis_einstein_writing_vlrgwidec
Writing Makes Photographers More Creative — 5 Easy Tips
Daniel Pink: The Power of Regret
Chris Hutchins of Chase Jarvis LIVE
Chris Hutchins: All the Hacks to Maximize Your Life
Chris Burkard on Chase Jarvis LIVE
The Wayward Path of Photographer Chris Burkard
Make Your Message Heard with Victoria Wellman

36 replies on:
War & Fashion – Intellectual Exercise or Gut Punch?

Comments navigation

Previous
Next
  1. tubebroadcastyourself.com says:
    August 30, 2014 at 2:27 am

    Unlike in television, time slots are restricted, and it is
    therefore not ideal for those who are busy at work. I met a girl, Stephanie, who had a talk show on local
    cable access. Following are a few tips for maximizing the
    effectiveness of your You – Tube publicity campaign:.

  2. การทำ seo says:
    August 18, 2014 at 9:58 pm

    SERP rankings (the level of your site in the ranking pages) are most heavily
    impacted by keywords, making the ranking a factor of major significance.

    This keeps both readers and search spiders on your site longer.
    Taking the step into the murky waters of the internet
    world can be a little worrisome, especially if you have never had your own website before.

  3. sacred 3 trainer pc says:
    August 4, 2014 at 2:58 am

    I know this website gives quality dependent articles or reviews and other stuff, is there any other web page which gives such
    things in quality?

  4. Google says:
    July 23, 2014 at 12:53 pm

    These are the basics on how to get your site to the top of google through article marketing.
    The facia is dominated by a generously proportioned
    4 inch super AMOLED capacitive touchscreen which utilises a pixel layout of 480x
    800 to display up to 16 million colours. After you run your search, you’ll find
    the PPC ads on the right-hand side of the screen.

  5. Electronic Dance MusicVideo ProducerRAY.VS says:
    July 22, 2014 at 6:58 am

    The Melbourne Shuffle originated from the underground music scene in Australia during the 1980s and
    is danced to electronic music. One of the largest holographic projections
    to date was in South Africa in 2007. More important, perhaps, is what a brand name
    says about the other students who will attend a school with a high reputation.

Comments navigation

Previous
Next

Comments are closed.

BUY NEVER PLAY IT SAFE NOW!

Get weekly, curated access to the best of everything I do.

Popular Posts

20250812_CJLIVE_JimMurphy_Thumb_16x9_v2.5How to Stay Calm Under Pressure and Perform Your Best When It Matters Most
The show's logo is displayed on the left side, with "THE CHASE JARVIS LIVE" in bold black text inside yellow rectangles, stacked vertically. The right side of the image features a robotic figure, resembling a humanoid robot, meticulously working on a canvas. The robot is painting or drawing a grayscale portrait of a human-like figure. The robot's detailed mechanical components are visible, and the scene evokes themes of artificial intelligence, creativity, and technology. The background is minimal, allowing focus on the robot and its artwork. The composition suggests an exploration of AI's role in creative processes.Is AI the End of Creativity or Just the Beginning?
20250611_CJLIVE_RoryVaden_Thumb_16x9_v2.5You’ve Been Focused on the Wrong Thing… Here’s What Really Matters
20250118_CJLIVE_LifeIsLong_Micro_Thumb_16x9_v2.5Signs You’re Drifting Away from Your Purpose (and How to Get Back on Track)
20250812_BeyondTheHype_Micro_Thumb_16x9_v2.5Beyond the Hype: The Truth About Creativity in the AI Era
20250611_CJLIVE_ToDoList_Micro_Thumb_16x9_v2.5What If There’s No Rulebook? Here’s How to Write the One You Need
20250702_CJLIVE_PillarsOfMastery_Micro_Thumb_16x9_v2.5Struggling to Improve? This Could Be Why Your Practice Isn’t Paying Off Yet
202500507_CJLIVE_SorenGordhamer_Thumb_16x9_v2.5How to Find What Really Matters in a World Full of Noise
20250312_CJLIVE_DebbieMillman_Thumb_16x9_v2.5Stop Hiding Behind ‘Not Ready’ and Learn How to Begin Anyway
20250224_CJLIVE_DontLetYourDreamsDie_Micro_Thumb_16x9_v2.5How to Trust Your Gut (Even When Fear Tells You Not To)

Daily Creative Projects

© 2024 Chase Jarvis. All rights reserved.